HIGH Great use of Remedy’s Control aesthetic for a team shooter.
LOW Little interaction between the different weapon classes.
WTF Don’t ask about Sticky Ricky…
HIGH Great use of Remedy’s Control aesthetic for a team shooter.
LOW Little interaction between the different weapon classes.
WTF Don’t ask about Sticky Ricky…
HIGH The game’s aesthetics and visual style.
LOW The slow-paced start and abrupt ending!
WTF Why do I need a supercomputer to run this?!?
A Lesson In Payne HIGH Bullet time shoot-outs in noir noughties aesthetics. LOW Platforming challenges WTF This game is my age — and now I feel so old. Max Payne comes from the perplexing minds of Sam Lake and Remedy Entertainment. Released in 2001, it’s often hailed as the earliest […]

HIGH Turning Assist Mode on and burning through the back half.
LOW Darkness is one of the worst videogame gimmicks, ever.
WTF Alan’s barely in this.

HIGH It’s more Control!
LOW The “Swift Platform” mission needs work.
WTF Something went horribly wrong with the lipsyncing.

HIGH The combat consistently made my pulse pound.
LOW The checkpoint system.
WTF That… was the ending?

HIGH The time-loop premise and Twilight Zone voiceovers.
LOW A hard-locked 360 and stuttering framerates in the second cycle.
WTF Collecting manuscript pages again?

HIGH Increased use of the game's psychological elements.
LOW The combat is infuriatingly cheap and unbalanced.
WTF The Signal's product placement for Verizon is unbelievably blunt.

Alan Wake is certainly not a terrible title, but it is repetitive and fairly underwhelming—doubly so for a game that's been in development for more than five years. I give credit to the developers for some beautiful environments and a combat style that's sensible and engaging, but it's weak in most other areas. I also have to say that for a game that's been so heavily touted for its story, I found the plot to be poorly-structured and unsatisfying.

HIGH The external environments are beautiful.
LOW The player sees far too much of them.
WTF The amount of back-attacks and birds.